Right to farm right to harm

Image credit: We Animals

The NSW animal welfare laws are currently under review and the NSW Government says that "protecting the welfare of animals is a priority" for the Government. In its submissions to the review, Vegan Australia argues that if the welfare of animals really matters to the Government then the only way to stop the suffering of the almost half a million animals bred, raised and killed in NSW for food every day is to stop farming them. The laws should fully protect the interests of animals. The goal of the laws should be to completely phase out the use of animals for any purpose, including animal agriculture.

Read our submission below.

Submission on the NSW Animal Welfare Reform Discussion Paper

Vegan Australia is pleased to have the opportunity to provide general comments on the Discussion Paper of the NSW Animal Welfare Reform.

Vegan Australia is a national vegan organisation that aims to promote veganism to the broader Australian public. Vegan Australia envisions a world where all animals live free from human use and ownership. Compassion is the foundation of Vegan Australia - compassion towards animals, people and the earth. Vegan Australia believes that the starting point for people to put this compassion into action is to become vegan and to encourage others to become vegan.

One of the priorities of Vegan Australia is to raise awareness about the rights of animals. The rights we refer to are simple and based on the sentience of animals. Firstly, the right of an animal to their life. Second, the right of an animal to their body. And third, the right of an animal to freedom. Life, body, freedom. These rights should be respected by all humans and humans should not use or exploit animals or treat them as objects or property.

Vegan Australia believes that the public consultation on the NSW Animal Welfare Reform is an opportunity to reflect on our use of farmed animals for food, clothing and other products, on animals used in entertainment, and on animals impacted in other ways by humans. It is an opportunity to consider alternative products that promote compassion and put an end to the unnecessary suffering and killing of over 150 million animals each year for food in NSW.

To connect agricultural practices to the rights of animals, we see that the killing of these animals is an obvious abuse of their right to their lives; the suffering throughout their lives caused by the treatment by humans is an abuse of their right to bodily integrity and their confinement is an abuse of their right to freedom.

The fact is that all this suffering and killing is for no good reason. Humans have no need for any animal products and in particular are able to live healthily on a plant based diet. This is the view of most national health bodies, including the Australian Dietary Guidelines.

The reform of the NSW animal welfare laws is an excellent opportunity for the Government to really make the welfare of animals the primary goal of the law, by enforcing that animals must not be used in any way.

The discussion paper states that "protecting the welfare of animals is a priority of the NSW Government." Vegan Australia submits that animals' welfare and security would best be met by them not being used by humans in any way and that the law should be used to protect their interests only.

Regarding farmed animals, if their welfare really matters to the Government then the only way to stop the suffering of the almost half a million animals bred, raised and killed in NSW every day is to stop farming them.

To this end, Vegan Australia recommends that the laws be modified to fully protect the interests of animals. The goal of the laws should be to completely phase out the use of animals for any purpose, including animal agriculture. Animals value their own life and body and have an interest in continuing their existence and avoiding suffering. They have the right to be treated with respect and justice and not to be treated as property.

Production of products from animals necessarily results in the suffering and/or death of individual animals. Humans have no need for any products from animals, including for meat, milk or other products. Since there are non-animal based alternatives to all these products, the breeding, raising, using and killing of animals is not necessary for humans to live.

Vegan Australia believes that the pleasure of taste of the flesh or milk of an animal and the utility of other animal products do not outweigh the pain, suffering and death caused to individual animals that is an integral part of the production of these products. No reforms, laws or standards will be enough to change this.

The laws should take into account the well accepted scientific principles that animals are sentient, that humans have no need for any animal products and that the animal industries are having a significant negative impact on the environment.

First, farmed animals are sentient, emotional and social animals. Sentience means they are aware of their physical and social environment, they able to feel fear, pain and distress as well as happiness and pleasure. Farmed animals have emotions and needs just as human beings do. They react emotionally to their own achievements and are self-aware.

The Victorian Department of Primary Industries states that "all livestock species (and fish) have the necessary brain structures and nervous system to allow them to feel pain and suffer". In addition "all livestock species are capable of comprehending and desiring pleasurable experiences."

Second, humans have no need for any animal foods and are able to live healthily on a vegan diet. There is clear evidence of not only the health benefits of a well-balanced vegan diet, but of the significant health costs of consuming animal products. Many people who adopt a nutritious vegan diet will enjoy significant health improvements by reducing the risk of major killers such as heart disease, stroke, cancer and diabetes.

Third, raising and processing of animals for food is a major cause of environmental damage, including land degradation, water shortage, deforestation, ocean degradation, air pollution and climate change. We must take into account the costs to the environment of the animal agriculture industry, including to soils, waterways, forests and native vegetation and its contribution to global warming.

Together these principles suggest that the animal welfare laws should not suggest "better" ways to dehorn, disbud, tail dock, castrate, use an electric prodder, electro-immobilise, induce, spay, web, tie up, brand with a hot iron, tag, tattoo, electro-ejaculate, inseminate, intensively house, pen and kill farmed animals, whether by shooting, captive bolt, electrocution or cutting the throat. They should state that none of these procedures should be necessary. They should give guidance on how to eliminate this industry and replace it with an industry based on compassion for animals, people and the earth.

In conclusion, we recommend that the NSW animal welfare laws be modified to prohibit the use, exploitation and ownership of any sentient being. This should include the phasing out of the animal agriculture industry and should be implemented within a reasonable time scale of about 10 years.

Greg McFarlane
Director
Vegan Australia

Links
Vegan Australia submission in pdf
NSW Department of Primary Industries website for Animal Welfare Reform

Links
See our other Campaigns & Submissions
National Crocodile 'Code of Practice' Revision
In February 2024, we maximised the number of public submissions to this government inquiry to make a meaningful impact on farmed crocodiles.
Read more
Victorian Pig Welfare Inquiry
In January 2024, we maximised the number of public submissions to this government inquiry to make a meaningful impact on farmed pigs.
Read more
Tax Office urged to permit tax-deductible donations
Charities that work to protect and promote the rights of animals play a crucial role in creating a compassionate and just society, but often face fina...
Read more
the vegan australia team holding a vegan sausage sizzleSizzle For Change
Our newest project involves helping aligned nonprofits across Australia host vegan sausage sizzle fundraisers.
Read more
supermarket well stocked with a variety of vegetablesFood security inquiry told to shift away from animal agriculture
A government inquiry into food security in Australia has been told to transition the agricultural system away from animal production to other uses of ...
Read more
Vegan input given to Preventive Health Strategy inquiry
Vegan Australia recently made a submission to the Australian Department of Health on its Draft National Preventive Health Strategy. The submission (be...
Read more
Vegan Australia is an animal rights organisation that campaigns nationally for veganism. 
Sign up for our newsletter

Newsletter Sign Up

Name(Required)
Privacy(Required)
linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram